May Cycles and Savage Harvest

I’ve long known that the word here in Canada is that you’re supposed to wait — to be on the safe side — till after the May long weekend holiday (which was last weekend) before planting your summer annuals and garden. I always want to jump the gun, but no, I guess it’s best to be prudent and follow the local wisdom. After all it did snow in town last weekend, but luckily now the sun is back so we’re in the clear from here on out … right?

My husband and I followed our May long-weekend tradition of participating in the annual three-day Golden Triangle bike ride in the mountains, which is a local club ride of about 400 cyclists going over 100 km per day.
We had a good time, and only got drenched on Day 2, when it rained and was cold all day. Not good. But we biked on, taking in the sights and avoiding hypothermia.

During Day 1 my husband came across a Mama grizzly and her cub by the side of the road. He kept his distance and biked past them. Later that evening we went back up the canyon by car to take pictures, and saw the same two bears again. They were busy munching on grass and dandelions by the ton. I was worried they were so close to the road where vehicles were whizzing by at 60 to 70 mph that they would be hit, but apparently the bears know the area and often manage these precarious situations.

All in all, it was a great weekend, which started off with a bang on Friday evening when our public library hosted authors Chris Cleave and Michael Crummey together for a reading and talk. I repeat Chris Cleave and Michael Crummey came here! Two authors I really like. Good gracious it was wonderful. I just had seen Cleave the week before at Book Expo and now he was following me to my town. What’s going on?! This is no cultural mecca. I was so pleased to hear them both. I have read Cleave’s three prior novels, and I look forward to his new one “Everyone Brave Is Forgiven,” which is based loosely on the love letters his grandparents wrote to each other during WWII. Apparently his grandfather was stationed on Malta during the war and he was separated from his wife for three and a half years. Cleave gave an interesting slide show of his grandparents and London during the Blitz. His novel is a tribute to them and a meditation on courage, Cleave said, and I’m sure it will be a weeper. Have you read it?

As for Canadian author Michael Crummey, I really liked his novel “Sweetland” last year, about an old man who refuses to leave a remote island off Newfoundland when the mainland government decides to resettle the population. It quietly blew me away and made me say: “Who is this guy? I need to read more of his books.” Crummey has written a few novels and some excellent poetry collections as well. He was there reading from his latest book of poetry called “Little Dogs,” which made me realize I must find time for reading poetry! Crummey’s writing often draws on the history and landscape of his native Newfoundland and Labrador. Both of which I would like to visit someday.

As for books last week, I finished the audiobook of Carl Hoffman’s 2014 nonfiction work “Savage Harvest: A Tale of Cannibals, Colonialism, and Michael Rockefeller’s Tragic Quest for Primitive Art.” Oh my, I didn’t know much about Michael’s sad fate before getting into this, but now I feel I know it from almost every angle. It’s safe to say author Carl Hoffman became very obsessed in solving the long-ago disappearance of 23-year-old Michael Rockefeller, who vanished in 1961 off the coast of New Guinea when his boat overturned. Did Rockefeller drown trying to swim to shore as his family believes? Or did he make it to shore only to be killed and eaten by a remote cannibalistic Asmat tribe? (No body was ever found.)

In this book Hoffman provocatively makes the case — after much research and time in the Asmat region among the people — that the tribe killed Rockefeller and was avenging the deaths of members of its group at the hands of whites years earlier. He also suggests there was a Dutch cover-up in hiding what truly happened to Michael.

Admittedly I’m a sucker for such vanishing stories of influential people whether it’s the tragic cases of Amelia Earhart over the Pacific, or the Lindbergh baby — I found Michael Rockefeller’s story similarly entrancing, especially since it was more than 50 years ago. Hoffman’s book includes a lot about the tribes in the Asmat region: their history, society, and the tropical jungles and conditions in which they lived. So if you like anthropology, like I do, this book could be your cup of tea. But fair warning: some of the descriptions in the book are graphic and violent. It’s not exactly Disneyland there. Hoffman also provides context of what was going on under Dutch colonialism then and circumstances surrounding Rockefeller’s death and what he was doing collecting primitive art there at the time.

I was impressed by Hoffman’s research and how he put himself into the story and experienced the tribes much like Rockefeller did. He seemed drawn to Michael and his pursuits in the remote tribal world. But I also thought there were times when Hoffman’s ideas seemed presumptuous and that he was over the top in solving the case.

As the book goes on, Hoffman’s theories swirl round and round and get a bit repetitive. No doubt it’s a thorough and exhaustive exploration of Michael Rockefeller’s disappearance, but the book likely would have been better if it had been a bit shorter and more focused. While I listened to “Savage Harvest” as an audiobook, on second thought I would have rather have liked to read it — as there are many foreign proper nouns in it that would have been easier to follow in print. Still the audio kept me intrigued. (Kudos to Joe Barrett for his excellent narration.)

I kept thinking Hoffman would unveil a smoking gun in the case, but alas — although what he finds out is quite convincing and stunning — it’s not a totally done deal. Whatever happened to Michael Rockefeller perhaps will never be fully known, but I’m glad to have learned about him through this journey.

What about you have you read “Savage Harvest” or about Michael Rockefeller before? Or have you read any of the books by Chris Cleave or Michael Crummey — and if so, what did you think?

This entry was posted in Books. Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to May Cycles and Savage Harvest

  1. Brian Joseph says:

    It looks like you had a great bike trip.

    I have not read Savage Harvest but what I know about Michael Rockefeller seems very interesting. I think that I would like this book.

    • Susan Wright says:

      Thanks Brian. Yes I think you would like the book about Rockefeller. That author went all out on his disappearance!

  2. Carmen says:

    Yay for the ride bike. The pic of the grizzlies is priceless!
    I haven’t read any of the books that you mention, but Savage Harvest got me thinking, what makes the author think that Rockefeller made it to the island and got eaten instead of drowning which could be a surer and possibly more boring way to die?!

    • Susan Wright says:

      Thanks Carmen. Yeah I think the author thinks that because of all of the rumors and talk at the time from some who were there that the Tribe did it. But it’s still a bit inconclusive — he didn’t totally get a confession which is was hoping for. And I’m still not totally sure the distance Rockefeller would’ve had to swim to shore — Wikipedia says 12 miles, which seems a lot — but perhaps it’s doable for a 23 year old. ?

  3. Naomi says:

    I wish I could have come to your library that night! I loved Little Bee, but haven’t read any of Cleave’s other books. But I’ve read all of Crummey’s novels and can recommend every one. I have yet to read his short stories or poems, though. I would if I had them – I don’t know why they are proving harder to find in the used book stores and sales.

    Your weekend biking sounds like fun (except for the rain). Our bike trip with the kids last year included one half day of rain, which wasn’t much fun. But the kids were troopers. The next day was sunny and it didn’t take long before everything was dry again. Great shot of the grizzlies!

    • Susan Wright says:

      Thanks Naomi. Yes I must admit I was really impressed by the poetry that Crummey read at the library talk, which I wouldn’t mind getting. But I’d love to read another novel of his. Perhaps the River Thieves, which was his debut. Hmm. Are you planning to do your annual family bike trip again? It’s such a great idea.

  4. I tried Savage Harvest but faltered. Maybe I need to pick it back up or try the audio.

    • Susan Wright says:

      The audio can be a bit to follow because of all the foreign names but I did manage to see it through. An unusual and tragic mystery.

  5. Oh, I am drawn to stories about people who have gone missing, have disappeared, or ended up dead under mysterious circumstances.

    In 1983, my older brother, a professor and a bit of a quirky adventurer, was doing research in Belize…and was found, supposedly, dead a few days later, and unrecognizable, but identified because of papers near the body. I say “supposedly,” because the ID was suspicious, IMO, and even the State Department wouldn’t say anything for sure. Not allowed to open the casket. Okay, enough of gruesome info.

    All these years later, I am still waiting to finally learn what really happened.

    I can relate to family members who are still wondering.

    Great photos, and I am envious of living in Canada…a friend and I are threatening to move there if Trump is elected…LOL.

    • Susan Wright says:

      Oh my, Laurel, I’m so sorry about your brother. How awful. I can imagine how haunting that would be — not to have any real resolution. Ugh. I had no idea you had been through that. so sorry.
      You’re welcome to come to Canada if Trump is elected !! And we will build a wall here against him, LOL.

  6. Jillann says:

    Hi Susan,
    I’m a big fan of Michael Crummey’s fiction and can recommend The Wreckage. I loved Sweetland last year too! I’ll have to read a Chris Cleave novel….
    I heard Michael Crummey read from Galore one year at the Kingston Writersfest (also Joseph Boyden, Steven Heighton and Mark Sinnett at the same event!) .
    Jillann

    • Susan Wright says:

      Wow Thanks Jillann. I’m a newbie to Crummey and now after loving Sweetland must read more. I will look for The Wreckage. I’m curious about his book River Thieves too. I’d like to attend the Kingston Writersfest one of these days! A lot of great authors there. Keep me posted if you come across some really great reads this summer. thanks for writing.

  7. Judy Krueger says:

    I have been traveling myself and mostly went off the internet. Catching up now. Your biking is impressive! I was not a fan of Little Bee and have not read Crummey yet, though I intend to. But I am reading poetry again: Collected Poems of W B Yeats, bought when I was in Ireland some years ago and we went to Ben Bulben. His poetry just drips with sorrow.

    • Susan Wright says:

      Thanks Judy. & Welcome back. It’s nice to step away from the internet occasionally. I’d like to get into poetry too. Crummey’s poems seemed accessible to me. We’ll see how it goes. Enjoy your Yeats.

  8. JaneGS says:

    Seeing bears on your bike trip is awesome–I’ve never actually seen a bear in the wild despite having a cabin in the Colorado mtns for over ten years. The pictures were wonderful, but I couldn’t help thinking that bears in the spring are bad tempered from hunger!

    I’ve read a couple of reviews of Everyone Brave is Forgiven, and my husband got a copy and started it, and I’m eager to read it after him. My parents were of the generation that fought and held down the fort during WWII in England, so it is close to home for me, and it sounds excellent.

    Sweetland sounds interesting–I like stories that blend personal conviction with nature and home.

    Not sure Savage Harvest would make it on my TBR list–grim and theoretical, but potentially fascinating.

    • Susan Wright says:

      Thanks Jane, liked all your comments. I can’t believe you’ve never seen a bear in the wild — with your cabin. I guess it’s sad there’s not more in Colorado. I lived there 3 years in the 1980s, and only saw one — which was right in town in Aspen the fall. Surprised the heck out of me. In spring here in the mountains, the bears are extremely hungry and are eating along side of the road voraciously. Just a few, we usually see. I look forward to hearing if you like Everyone Brave Is Forgiven, and will stop by your site. Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.